3 Comments
User's avatar
Tom's avatar

I don’t agree that we (City) were lucky to escape with a point last night. We didn’t play well at all but there seems to have been a huge overreaction to United’s performance - they’ve improved since the start of the season but were ok at best.

But yes, our defence is a mess. I’m hopeful the return of Knaak will make a difference. We’ve missed her, and we make up for her lack of pace with two things: her intelligence, and Jade Rose’s speed.

So I’m not sure what Jeglertz does. Knaak and Greenwood are too slow to play together in the middle, so does he play Rose with Knaak and move Greenwood to the left? But then Greenwood can’t bomb down the left like Charles or Wamser can. So, in order of likelihood, he can a) move Greenwood to the left and sacrifice an attacking left wing-back b) not change anything and keep Knaak as backup or c) drop Greenwood. I guess we might find out v PSG on Thursdsay.

Joel's avatar

The standard for a good performance is higher for City than it is for United at this moment in time because City are in a better state. Most people (including me) compare the two teams while taking that into context. City didn't perform at their best but United put in their best performance of the season and the teams were more or less equal.

With regards to what Andrée does when Knaak comes back, I don't think there's one solution. It should vary from game to game. As I say in the piece, some of the defensive issues are due to him rotating because he wants to get everyone up to speed at the start of the season. The aim is that by -- say February, you build relationships between everyone on the pitch so rotation hurts City less than it does now.

I dount we ever see Greenwood and Knaak as a CB pairing because managers rarely play left footers at right center-back but for some games you could play Greenwood at LB if you want a defensive option, if you think you need more in attack, you opt for the more attacking full-backs etc

Tom's avatar

Well we certainly looked much more solid last night with Rose and Knaak at centre back and Greenwood on the left.

I predict we’ll line up the defence like that again on Sunday but with Wamser in for Casparij. I’ll probably be wrong. I think us City fans might just need to embrace the chaos while Jeglertz figures out what to do.